Poor patterns, weak target hits, and uninspiring features all contributed to our low grade for this shooting tool. Written and photographed by Ralph Winingham, using evaluations from Gun Tests team testers. This Model 725 Field was no exception. Add in the sub-par patterning performance, plus some ineffective target busting time on the range, and our shooters said the new 828U stack-barrel does not live up to the standards of the high-quality semiautomatic firearm innovator. It was the worst over under I've ever shot. If youve got a computer and a pen, you can probably work with it. Buddy of mine bought one because he duck hunted with s SBE. Realize, too, that this was legitimate wild-bird hunting among wide-open crop fields and across rolling terrain that was as natural as pheasant habitat gets. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. It seems like the 828U Sport is a better gun than the original/field model 828U, certainly so for clay shooting. A guy at a field trial I was at a year ago had one and I really liked it. I might sell a kidney to get one. The 828 is a design that had serious potential, but is extremely lacking in configuration and execution. Have you seen one or held one? Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Looks goofy as can be, like a camo space gun, but I use it for upland, waterfowl, and turkeys and without an issue. The 828U is a lightweight gunimportant for a long session of upland hunting in which it is likely to be carried much more of the time than it is shotbut it is the distribution of the weight that is key. The benelli 828u pen is a small, high quality, battery operated pen. But around 2012, Benelli engineers, spurred by the belief that they could contribute something new to traditional shotgunning, quietly began work on an over-under that would be engineered like none before it. To whatever extent we guessed where they were headed merely validated the instincts of a company that manages to stay one step ahead of the market. Overall, no major complaints were registered regarding the 828Ua testimony to the guns overall design. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. 8 shot and an average muzzle velocity of 1,200 fps. To consistently break targets, particularly those with any distance on them, we had to hold high and right, not the accepted and typical practice of shooting where you look. I thought it felt very much like my super vinci in regards to the balance and mounting. This caused the Benelli to be a little harder to move into targets similar to the movement required to push a semiautomatic through targets rather than the glide-through handling of a well-balanced over and under. The sporting model is almost $4000. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! The breech block also contains the spring-loaded firing pins, making them easily replaceable should the need arise. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Be ready for some hate. Key to the 828Us operation is a steel breech block that engages corresponding surfaces on the monobloc as the action is closed, containing the firing forces. Thomas Jefferson. The stock A subject close to my heart, and one I can grasp more easily than the benefits of a replaceable breech face, is gun fit. Instead I have a set of four rather specific questions that I think are appropriate to ask to the group of (knowledgeable) strangers on this forum. Phillips-head screws hold the pad in place, which, once removed, allows access to the Progressive Comfort module. When I tried an 828U for real the felt-recoil was more than I'd want on a 100 target round - even on 24grm shells . We had plenty of semi-automatics, so we wanted to go in a complementary sector by adding a product that would match the needs of other Benelli customers, said Vignaroli. One of the problems with using it is that I cant write without it, and it is really tough to write without it. Rather, the guns strikers are cocked by operating the top-mounted opening lever. Again, unlike shotguns of old, which required fitting by an expert and labor-intensive, permanent changes to the stock, the Benelli system is relatively simple to customize by the end user simply by referring to a fitting table in the owners manual. You are using an out of date browser. It is a nice color, and is the perfect size to comfortably hold in one hand. My friend that I go to S.D. Hardly ever. I tried the 828U a couple months ago. When innovation and inspiration collided the 828U was born - the first over/under worthy of the Benelli badge. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); You have entered an incorrect email address! We pitted the Benelli 828U, retailing for $2,500, against the Browning 725, retailing for $2,470, both at the clay-target range and on the patterning board to see if the new smokepole performed as advertised against a proven product sitting in the rack beside it. I did get an exceptional deal on it. In the past I've found that Gunbroker is not a reliable indicator of street price, though I certainly could be wrong on this one. Download the appropriate manual for your Benelli shotgun or rifle. For younger shooters or shooters with shorter arms, the new Benelli 828U Compact comes with a 26-inch barrel and 14-inch length of pull, shortened from the 828U's original 14 3/8 inches. So we had to pay particular attention to the right angle and the right ergonomics of this lever through its geometry, Vignaroli said. I forced it open and sent it in to Benelli who fixed it and sent it back to me. Hosts Mark and Robin Braatens comfortable lodge provided an ideal setting in which I was able to discuss the guns design with the Urbino-based engineer who spearheaded it: Marco Vignaroli. Your Worst Nightmare About benelli 828u problems Come to Life - Skeet Action Shooting Your Worst Nightmare About benelli 828u problems Come to Life If you take a look at some of the videos that I have been sharing on YouTube, you will see that people are not always sure what they are doing. In a classic example of premature innovation, we found the new Benelli 828U simply did not function, feel, or perform as well as a veteran Browning Citori 725 when fired head to head. We should note that the version of the Benelli made available to us was a 26-inch-barrel anodized-aluminum receiver model, while the Browning provided featured 28-inch barrels and a silver nitrite receiver. Two versions are available: one with a black anodized receiver and one with a silver-tone receiver said to be the result of a nickel-based treatment. Benelli 828U Steel Specifications Chamber: 12- and 20-gauge (2 3/4- and 3-inch) Barrel Length: 26, 28, 30 in. Press J to jump to the feed. The swing was beautiful but the recoil destroyed me. Benelli has very little experience with over/unders. My buddy bought one for a retirement present for himself. Both versions have sold very poorly and have had issues. Kicked like a mule. 712 shot shells at a range of 30 yards, we found the Modified choke in the top barrel produced a 57-43 percent pattern (57 percent above the center and 43 percent below) and the Improved Cylinder choke in the bottom barrel produced a 62-38 percent pattern. The most notable difference is that the 828 features a floating steel breech block within its' aluminum receiver. She appreciated the buttpad for not hanging up on clothing, liked the matte finish of the carbon-fiber rib and pointed out that the removable breech block would make cleaning easier. Further isolating the fore-end and barrels from the receiver are what Benelli refers to as impulse activated ejectors. A point of potential mechanical wear, the hinge pins, while relatively small in diameter, are made of steel and serve only to pivot the monobloc on the receiver. They include (l.): a shim kit that offers 40 different combinations of cast and drop adjustment; the Progressive Comfort recoil-mitigation module that resides within the buttstock; and interchangeable cheekpieces that can be swapped out to provide proper stock-to-face fit. My daughter can't move the safety lever and it takes me some good pushing. Both receivers are sculpted to evoke the wings of a mallard in flight. Though I wouldnt recommend it, I would love to see how it works with the other benelli pens. Think I'll just order from soortsmans and they say i can always decline it when it shows up if it's not my cup of tea. So, when the first rooster got up quite behind me, I simply turned and swung the gun in its direction, keeping my eye on its beak and firing as soon as I could. They each have their strengths. the past 2 yrs. There were 202 hits in the 20-inch circle with the Modified choke and 164 hits with the Improved Cylinder choke. I hear it's dead easy to disable, but blimey the number of swear words during out 60 clay trying was rather large :-) 2) During our test, there was a case where the gun didn't close. I know the guy that bought it but in the year of Covid I haven't had an opportunity to ask him about it. https://www.cabelas.com/shop/en/benelli er-shotgun. Thanks for the replies. However, we noticed there was a little creep or spongy feel to the pull with both triggers, unlike the crisp, sharp pull of the Browning. A few media representatives were let in on the then-secret project during a mid-year 2013 trip to Italy, where they were asked to contribute ideas about what a new and different Benelli should be. This, despite its low build cost, means that the 828U is a product condemned to please no one. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Has anyone tried the Performance Shop version? Benellis Over/Under Shotgun Cant Beat Browning, Low profile silver nitride, with roll engraving, Grade II/III checkered walnut, gloss oil finish. You could do most of this research yourself. With that being said, every gun I have bought I have shot beforehand, so it would be uncharacteristic for me to buy one without trying it, though it is clear there aren't many of these around. I flew to another city and had to break down for checked bag as my case cannot fit it assembled. Advertisement Barrel & Receiver The 828U comes with 26, 28, or 30-inch barrels that have three-inch chambers. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. I have shot a few of them on Demo days next too several other O/U. of No. The 828U is what you would expect from Benelli - a hardworking, lightweight and low-recoil shotgun. Feb 5th, 2020. And the birds we encountered were not only tough and of good size, but wary, running and flushing sometimes hundreds of yards ahead of the dogs. The plate features four contact points with the barrel and moves forward and backward on springs as the shotgun is opened and closed. Overall, our test team members were satisfied with that configuration. The surprising part, though, was how nonintrusively it had done so. (12-gauge); 26, 28 in. I think that I had the barrel seared firmly in the receiver, like I said done this many times over quite a few years with other over under without issue. I have a pen that takes up a lot of space, and I really like the fact that I can carry both pens at the same time. My Browning Citori White Lighting 16 ga. feels just as good in my hands and about the same weight. It was the worst over under I've ever shot. I have heard that there are several people out there selling them for $100.00 each. Was a surprise to see him with it as he typically shoots a Perazzi. It's the OU that folks love to hate, I guess it bucks traditional builds and some folks just aren't receptive to that. Error Code pii_email_a42277285fa7a777ff7e Solved, Personally identifiable information PII doesnt belong in your email University Information Technology The University of Utah, How to Get Rid of the pii_email_e7ab94772079efbbcb25 Error. An Over-UnderFrom Benelli?There had been no hint that Benelli might venture into more traditional forms such as break-actions. To minimize this, the 828U cheekpiece has a replaceable Air Foam pad that cushions your face. The 828U makes some guys turn into hostile teenage girls. I do not recall the barrel length of this 828, it is at her place. Should not take a lot of force to snap closed. Maybe it's just me but I'm not a fan of field O/U's with aluminum receivers. It was one of the early models, so hopefully Benelli has that . Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a28dd07b9c52d16 Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. 10701 12 Gauge, $2,500 GUN TESTS GRADE: C Although Benelli has a reputation for producing high-quality semiautomatic shotguns, we found the company's new over/under was lacking in both appearance and performance. Women On Target Instructional Shooting Clinics, Volunteer At The Great American Outdoor Show, Marion P. Hammer Women Of Distinction Award, Women's Wildlife Management / Conservation Scholarship, National Youth Shooting Sports Cooperative Program, Weatherby Brings Back the Orion Over/Under Shotgun, Winchesters New King Buck Classic Youth Sporting Clays Event Will Have $10,000 In Prizes | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, Rifleman Q&A: St. Louis Arms Co. But Is It Really That Good?Prior to going afield with the 828U in South Dakota, our party of writers had the opportunity to try it on machine-thrown clays launched off a bluff at the ranch, which overlooks the scenic Missouri River Valley. Combine those conditions with several inches of snow on the ground and a temperature that failed to rise above the single digits, and the hunt proved to be the ideal opportunity to test the mettle of a gun that, at that point, still posed far more questions than it answered. It fit me very well (needed to switch to a lower drop shim). It is a pen that a lot of people use for writing, especially in college. Customer experience was, and still is, the primary focus, a key to the firms longevity and success. Back at the office, during the course of several weeks shooting in different settings and throughout several hundred shells worth of varied ammunitionwhether plastic- or paper-hulled, having high or low brass heads and in various payload weights and velocitiesan informal test group encountered no failures with our nickel-finish, 28"-barreled test sample. And they only weigh about 6.5 lbs. Have only shouldered one, never had a chance to shoot one. Beretta A400 Xcel "Black" Cole Special - Beretta A400 Xcel 20 Gauge - Beretta A400 28 Gauge -. A U-shaped spring steel wire clip attached to the cocking plate automatically activates the safety when the gun is broken open, but can be removed by the user to deactivate that feature. The trade-off in the field is that most shooters will take a lighter gun that carries better, because just one extra pound adds up over several miles of kicking pheasants up. I know it is a challenge to try, but I think it is a very good pen for writing. More importantly, everything it makes has the performance to match. So, How Does It Handle?Perhaps more than any other type of firearm platform, a shotgun is designed to function as an extension of the shooters body. Click to reveal Removing two more screws frees it for access to a nut on a stock bolt that fixes one of two metal drop plates. 712 shot with an average muzzle velocity of 1,180 fps. So maybe nearer 10,000 shells down the tubes and an intermittent problem has appeared when the gun is warm - the bottom barrel fails to fire, all I hear is that faintest of clicks - rather than the typical sound of a triggered firing pin, the primer of the shell is untouched (have eliminated low primers, changed brand of shell to no avail), when cool it's back to . I bought a Guerini instead with a kinetic balancer and love it. For our firing tests, we set up at the patterning range where we quickly discovered that the Crio Flush Fit chokes (Cylinder, Improved Cylinder, Modified, Improved Modified and Full) included with the package were not a match for the Browning. *What is the (approx) street price for a new 828u Sport? One was NRA Publications Editorial Director John Zent, an experienced upland hunter and clays shot. Pressing it fully through its arc first withdraws two barrel locking pins from their recesses in the monobloc then rotates a lever fitted with a roller within the receiver that presses back a cocking plate in the trigger module to load the striker springs. You don't want opinions on the gun, but that's the truth. I have held one at a gun store. Read today's "The Armed Citizen" entry for real stories of law-abiding citizens, past and present, who used their firearms to save lives. For a gun with some familiar features, such as a walnut buttstock and fore-end, the 828U also has quite a few unexpected innovations. The 828U makes some guys turn into hostile teenage girls. And due to the stupid barrel overlap at the receiver, you can't use sub gauge tubes. It is a pen that is also very expensive. The shotgun just does not have the feel and look of a standard over-and-under. An added benefit of the levers graceful design is that the shooting-hand thumb can rest naturally alongside it atop the receiver. If it doesn't fit you, look for a Browning 725 Sporting, Caesar Guerini Summit Sporting, even a Blaser F16 (used) is in the realm of possibilities. B Britlover Member Feb 19, 2020 #5 I bought one about 3 years ago. I bought a Guerini instead with a kinetic balancer and love it. In 2014, early production samples were unveiled during an upland hunt at Browns Hunting Ranch near the town of Gettysburg in the pheasant-rich game fields of South Dakota. We did find that the balance point of the shotgun was slightly behind the lightweight, aluminum receiver, rather than the preferred point right between the hands as with the Browning. It has a nice weight and balance, and has a battery that lasts up to 3 hours. The Benelli 828U is a major disappointment and an outright embarrassment. Zent, reflecting on those early discussions about the 828U in Italy, said of the gun that he was finally able to hold and shoot, I think what we see now is very close to what was on the drawing board then. We liked the feel and looks of the checkering on both the pistol grip and the newly designed forearm. Most noticeable is the shotguns patented locking mechanism that incorporates a free-floating locking plate in the front of the aluminum receiver.
Riverside Family Market Grindstone, Pa, Articles B