Wallace was waiting in . Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. Upset that Lorenz had called police about the skateboarders, Eldridge started the late-afternoon argument by shouting obscenities at Lorenz and then banged on the door and challenged him to a fight. The stories unravel from the neighbor who takes over the property next door to the feuding best friends and business partners Fear Thy Neighbor is in Delaware County in Pennsylvania to investigate the murder of Scott Robbins and the shooting of his stepdaughter, Kirsten Snow, by their neighbor, James (Jim) Dellavecchia. Really tough arent you? Lorenz and his wife cried yesterday as the verdict was read. Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger Circumstances:Annoyed with dog peeing on his lawn, Durens car rolled into his car and hit it causing minor damage, kids on skateboards were too loud, Bob called police & complained about neighbors multiple times, Bob yelled at the kids at Durens house, during confrontation at Bobs front door, Bob shot Duren with handgun and Duren died Add Image. A single mother gets along with her handyman neighbor, until her new boyfriend adopts more than 50 dogs. It's very difficult to review this case, as there, The FBi has been murdering people for years since their, Clearly its hard for some people to understand that although, What is taking so long? -Lake of Madness, Fear Thy Neighbors (S2, E2), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Lake of Madness on Investigation Discovery: Paul Crawford Executed Family Next Door, Then Killed Himself (April 20, 2015), ID Go: When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. was not a bully. Tracy Spencer Sentenced to Life in Prison for the Rape & Murder of Veteran Micki Filmore & Nurse Barbara Kramer (December 31, 1986), Air Force SSgt. A man who is meticulous about his lawn bickers with a new neighbor who doesn't have the same priorities; the feud between the two men escalates, ultimately ending in an episode of shocking violence. The narrator for the series is voice actress Tish Iceton. Investigation Discovery's ' Fear Thy Neighbor: Bloodshed on Beattie Street' probes this very case through interviews of law enforcement officials and people that knew Tony. The case was featured on "Kill-de-Sac," Fear Thy Neighbor (S2,E8) on @investigationdiscovery. Having money to hire a skilled, manipulative attorney does not constitute innocenceIt only lends to the theory of privilege amongst a portion of society that literally Gets away with Murder and more. Jeffrey Weigle and Dean Keller from Greenwood, Indiana. In a case that some legal specialists said pushes the boundaries of self-defense, a Loudoun County jury found Robert G. Lorenz, 54, not guilty of murder or manslaughter in the shooting death of Duren Wayne Eldridge, 31. LEESBURG, Va. (AP) _ A fastidious homeowner who shot a drunken neighbor in a dispute over teen-age skateboarders ripping up his flower beds was acquitted of murder Thursday after claiming self-defense. "Immediately prior to the shot, they heard the words Don't come into my house,' " Shaffer said. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. The Phillips' family moves to a quiet seafront town in Maine to escape a crime wave in Indiana. It's one. As a veteran myself, I find it funny that Bob couldnt fight, but quickly pulled out a gun to kill this man. Shows he had no concern for life. -Homes Where the Hearse Is, Fear Thy Neighbor (S1, E5), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Homes Where the Hearse Is on Investigation Discovery: Baldomero Fernandez Ended a Property Dispute with Fatal Violence (May 12, 2014), An elite California Lakeside Community is rocked to its core when two well-to-do gentlemen go to war over an 18-inch property line discrepancy. Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted Legal specialists said a claim of self-defense generally requires evidence that the person first tried to retreat from a threat, which prosecutors said Lorenz did not do. This makes me livid. Staff writers Victoria Benning and Peter Pae contributed to this report. Eldridge had spent the Sunday afternoon of the shooting drinking beer and "It was a tragedy for everyone involved. Battle lines are drawn, violence flares, and blood runs in the street. prized flower garden. im Durens daughter thank u for your words. You can email it to militaryjusticeforall@gmail.com. When a new tenant in a Harlem apartment building has his advances toward his upstairs neighbor rebuffed, his anger sets off a chain of accusations, threats and fights that culminate in bloodshed and shocking tragedy. Lorenz and the raucous family renting the house across the street, neighbors A couple moves to a tranquil California beach town and befriends their new neighbors - that is until one of the wives descends into drugs and madness, terrorizing the other. Think about it. confused by Eldridge's rantings and threats. This page was last edited on 4 February 2023, at 16:54. fear for his life or acted in anger. The series is an international co-production between the Canadian factual production company Cream Productions, the American cable television network Investigation Discovery, its . See production, box office & company info. Last month, she moved out of the neighborhood. Surveillance footage did show DePaul and Dempsey cross onto Hoyles property, but the pair were unarmed, and investigators concluded that they hadnt posed an immediate threat to Hoyle. The children survived, but their mother perished. Eldridge's widow, Peggy, left the courtroom without comment. With its strong, consistent ratings . A Leesburg man yesterday agreed to pay $30,000 to settle a $3.75 million wrongful-death suit filed after he was acquitted of murder after fatally shooting his neighbor following an argument over rowdy skateboarders. My heart goes out to victims families of this type of moral, physical and emotionally traumatic crimes. The conflict escalates until bullets fly and blood flows in the street. Lorenz, who had faced up to life in prison if convicted of murder, cried and hugged his family after the verdict. Fear Thy Neighbor takes you into the lives of horrific neighborly disputes. He wasnt in the best of shape to fight my friend I say that becuase im his grandson His young military days were over by that point and he was basically handicapped bro. Lorenz's attorney argued that he feared Eldridge was about to attack him. A dispute over access to a road causes tension between two Lopico, California neighbors. Management Agency and has no plans to move, his lawyer said. Perhaps what we're seeing here is some revision in that message.". He was a nice guy,'' she said. Eldridge, who had been drinking heavily before the argument, never displayed a weapon and did not enter Lorenz's house, according to trial testimony. 13 Jun. Two women with a shared wall between their townhouses become increasingly volatile with each other as their once good relationship disintegrates. Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor a child that's trying to piece together her life.". Danetta Henry was murdered by Alvin Dalton from Fresno, California. It should be a situation where a reasonable person would consider their life threatened.". Instead of the new start he was hoping for, a man's move to. The conflict escalates until bullets fly and blood flows in the street. Fear Thy Neighbor: 25 Veteran Cases Featured on InvestigationDiscovery, Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Kill-De-Sac on Investigation Discovery: Robert Lorenz Shoots Duren Eldridge, Claims Self-Defense, Acquitted of Murder (June 1,2015), Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor, Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor, Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted, Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger, Man Who Shot Neighbor to Pay $30,000 Settlement, Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (S2, E8), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (website), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (Amazon), Fear Thy Neighbor: 23 Veteran Cases Featured on Investigation Discovery, Follow MILITARY JUSTICE FOR ALL on WordPress.com, Senate Armed Services Subcommittee on Personnel Hearings: Sexual Assault in the Military (March 24,2021), Fort Hoods Toxic Culture? Or was it Hayes threatening kids, and tenants with a gun for the rent. The decision to build a fence after problems with dogs off the leash leads to bigger problems. After three days of deliberations, the jury acquitted Lorenz of first-degree murder and several lesser charges. believed he acted to save his life. coward and talked about fighting him over the police call, witnesses said. A defense psychologist testified Lorenz was so gripped by fear he could not The building of a backyard shed destroys a years-long close relationship between two neighbors and ignites a vicious conflict that sees property destroyed, pets killed, and finally, two people shot to death in cold blood. The April 9 incident stemmed from a disturbance several days earlier when skateboarders visiting Eldridge's 14-year-old stepdaughter rode over Lorenz's lawn and flower bed. And for those who do not have cable, you can watch unlocked episodes on the ID Go app including the latest premieres. Lorenz, who had faced up to life in prison if convicted of murder, cried and hugged his family after the verdict. A jury subsequently convicted Hoyle of two counts of first-degree murder and one count of possessing an instrument of crime. a day of escalating tension between them. No sympathy for your evil grandfather. Its acompilation of older seasons but totally worth the cost if you are a true crime addict. Location:Leesburg, Virginia The jury, which deliberated about 12 hours over three days, had the option Margaret Eldridge, who has moved to California and could not be reached for comment, had asked for $3.75 million to compensate for her husband's lost wages, the loss of companionship and her child's loss of a father, Fleming said. resolved itself,'' Shaffer said. So it was one dieing from being beat to death or one dieing by the gun.. Daniel Stewart, Jill Yousaf & Army Soldier James Catlin Conspired and Murdered Homeless Colorado Teen Maggie Fetty (November 30, 1991), Navy Master Chief John Bench Murdered Son & Attempted to Murder Wife & Daughter at Sasebo Naval Base in Japan; Died by Suicide in Motorcycle Crash (August 30, 2009), Army Spc. Prosecutors said Lorenz was in no danger from the unarmed Eldridge and had A family living in Florida becomes deathly ill after ingesting a rare poison and police believe that the family's next door neighbors could be to blame. ``Looking back on the case there is nothing I would Lorenz said he does not remember firing the fatal shot to Eldridge's chest. A jury acquitted a Leesburg man yesterday who said he acted in fear when he killed a rowdy neighbor on his front porch during a dispute over teenage skateboarders, even though the victim was unarmed and never entered his house. Although Lorenz was charged with first-degree murder, the jury could have convicted him of second-degree murder or manslaughter. #OnThisDay April 9, 1995, Duren Eldridge died in a confrontation with his neighbor Bob Lorenz. -Kill-De-Sac, Fear Thy Neighbor (S2, E8), Date: April 9,1995 Fear Thy Neighbor (2014-2022) Full Cast & Crew See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro Series Directed by Series Writing Credits Series Cast Series Produced by Series Music by Series Cinematography by Series Film Editing by Series Casting By Series Production Design by Series Art Direction by Series Set Decoration by Series Costume Design by Lorenz's yard; later, a car parked in Eldridge's driveway rolled backward into ``I speak for the Lorenz family when I say their hearts go out to the Prosecutors said that after Lorenz went back into his house and emerged with a .380-caliber semiautomatic handgun, he baited a retreating Eldridge, eventually shooting him once in the chest after a second brief round of yelling. After an early retirement, a man buys a duplex and rents half of it out to a troubled family. Fear Thy Neighbor: 23 Veteran Cases Featured on Investigation Discovery. Eldridges,'' defense attorney Mark Shaffer said. Eldridge's widow, Peggy, fled the courtroom without comment. The shooting was the culmination of months of tension between the quiet Lorenz, who works for the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and the raucous family renting the house across the street in suburban Washington. (August 21,2020), Military.com: Army Street Gang Activity Is Increasing, Internal Report Shows (August 17,2020), Marines Jesse Carson and Jason Blad Sentenced to Life in Prison for the Attempted Premeditated Murder of a 20 Year Old Woman in California (2000), Navy Lt. Verle Lee Hartley Died of Arsenic Poisoning in 1982; NCIS Cold Case Squad Solved Murder 13 Years Later; Wife Pamela Served 16 of 40 Years in Prison, Paroled (November 18, 1982), Army Reservist & Drexel University Security Guard David Dickson Murdered Deborah Wilson on Campus; Sentenced to Life in Prison (November 30, 1984), Army Spouse Melinda Stewart, Army Sgt. Several testified they don't believe Eldridge planned to hurt Lorenz, When he died, his blood-alcohol content was 0.16, twice the legal limit for driving in Virginia. Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. As accusations turn to threats, increasing anger ultimately leads to a bloody conclusion. "Most of us feel it was very unfortunate," said Comerford, 49. Do you, This was definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi. You know, till this day I have no idea why that man came over here. Related Links: Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor Where's the malice?". After the death of her husband, a woman becomes an obsession for her overly flirtatious neighbor. It's one person that is confrontational without reason and one surreptitiously annoying person. I lost my nephew and I dont get to see him grow old because of an irresponsible gun toting moron. Living in her family home, a woman befriends her new neighbors, only to be plunged into a nightmare of threats, violence and betrayal; after her brother steps up to protect her, blood will be spilled and lives will be shattered forever. Man Acquitted in Slaying of Neighbor bushes and flowers, neighbors said. We didn't have a running feud.". "If someone threatens to kill you, it doesn't matter. Two neighboring bachelors start out as friends; harmless banter turns into threats which eventually ignite an escalating war; the violence ends with a murder which is so shocking and almost beyond belief. One witness told how DePaul and Dempsey were constantly harassed by the Hoyle couple every time they were in their yard. Fear Thy Neighbor: Tony Coone vs. Bob Hayes. Betty Comerford, who lived next door to the Eldridges, called Lorenzs acquittal unfair. S8 E3 - The Next Door War. When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. a Lorenz vehicle, neighbors said. Throughout the afternoon, Eldridge had complained loudly that Lorenz was a ``Given Mr. Eldridge's state, there was no other way this could have Your grandfather intimidated his neighbors. Brian Spinks Stabbed 60+ Times by Jealous Girlfriend; Kimethia Coleman Sentenced to Life in Prison, No Parole (January 17, 2010), Forensic Files Premiered 'Plastic Puzzle': Navy Veteran Kirk Hudson Struck & Killed in Hit-And-Run Accident in Kalamazoo, Michigan (June 1, 2005), Navy Veteran Christopher Ingraham Jr. Fatally Shot While Sleeping; Girlfriend Katrina Bridges Found Guilty, Sentenced to 47 Years (January 4, 2001). Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor Danetta Henry was murdered by Alvin Dalton from Fresno, California. This one really got to me. [2] The narrator for the series is voice actress Tish Iceton.[3]. But Lorenz said the fatal shot was fired as Eldridge opened Lorenz's storm door and stepped toward the house. On the day the Eldridges moved in, their dogs relieved themselves on Lorenz yard. Thinking about you today. MAN WHO SHOT NEIGHBOR TO PAY $30,000 SETTLEMENT By Louie Estrada December 7, 1996 A Leesburg man yesterday agreed to pay $30,000 to settle a $3.75 million wrongful-death suit filed after he was.